SIR JOHN
“Wild Willy’s is appropriate for post-golf munchies, or a brief stop on a road-trip. It is inexpensive and it’s décor achieves the lunch wagon goal. However, the burger was lacking. A good stopping point, but not a destination.” Overall score: 19.5 (B)

SIR DAN
“As far as double-wides on the side of Route 1 go, you’d be hard pressed to find a tastier burger. Do us a favor though and accept a freakin’ credit card (or at least install an ATM!)” Overall score: 20 (B+)

SIR JOE
“Great spot to fill up the tank when time is of the essence.” Overall score: 19.75 (B)

SIR ROB
“Based on this visit and several others, this is still my favorite place to grab a burger during the day. The place is clean, fun, and the burgers are great. As a place for dinner though, it’s a bit casual. I’d stick with convincing your kid to use her hard-earned lemonade stand money to treat you to a tasty lunch.” Overall score: 19 (B)

SIR DAVE
“If hunger strikes on Rte. 1 in York there aren’t many choices. This, I suppose, is one of them. But personally I’d go the extra mile (on hands and knees if necessary) to eat at Mainiax Cafe instead.” Overall score: 9 (D+)

SIR JEFF
“Darn good for what I consider a pretty dive establishment. I really enjoyed my burger though it was somehow half medium and half well done.” Overall score: 18 (B)

Ye Verdict